Welcome, Guest. Please Login or Register.
Megaten Haven the SMT Bulletin Board
04/24/24 at 05:12:47
News:
Home Help Search Login Register


Poll
Question: Would You Want To See A Movie Adaption of SMT?

YES...but with full involvement from Atlus
NO...would bring the games too main stream
Movie for SMT 1,2 and Nocturne, no sub series
Games would not work as a movie
I Like Badgers
I'm A Spartan


« Created by: Angel Heart on: 03/30/08 at 19:05:52 »

Pages: 1 
Send Topic Print
SMT Movie (Read 12034 times)
Angel Heart
Less Newbies
*


The Devil That Lives
In Georgia

Posts: 32
Gender: male
SMT Movie
03/30/08 at 19:05:52
 
A friend and I where talking about how awful VG movie's tend to be and the subject of a Megaten movie came up. There all for it, I'm sorta against it. Any thoughts, opinions and so forth? Smiley
Back to top
 
 

Moo
View Profile   IP Logged
0kami7777
Junior Member
**


I Love Jack Frost!

Posts: 89
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #1 - 03/30/08 at 20:38:47
 
Last year a few of my freinds got together over the weekend and thought it would be funny to make what a trailer for a Persona 2 movie would look like (a mock trailer, not real). We filmed a few days worth of footage with our crappy school's camera and then we spliced up footage in iMovie. It was fun but the product is well...it's for laughs, trust me.
 
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B9OvPtm8qZs
 
Enjoy. And be thankful that there isn't a SMT movie. Though if planned out, I'm sure a stand-alone story wouldn't be too half bad.
Back to top
 
 
View Profile   IP Logged
Spider Bike
Senior Member
****




Posts: 350
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #2 - 03/30/08 at 22:05:40
 
This poll needs a "no" option.
Back to top
 
 
View Profile   IP Logged
Brand
YaBB Administrator
*****


I Love Jack Frost!

Posts: 269
Gender: female
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #3 - 04/01/08 at 23:09:26
 
Quote from Alizarin on 03/30/08 at 22:05:40:
This poll needs a "no" option.

I agree.
 
Video game movies have pretty much been proven to be crap.  I don't think it's worth it, it would be more painful then anything.
Back to top
 
 
View Profile WWW   IP Logged
EzraSolomon
Less Newbies
*


Mind Your True Bee

Posts: 21
Gender: male
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #4 - 04/15/08 at 23:43:31
 
>> I think an SMT movie could work if they played to the horror/invasion aspect, a la The Host or Cloverfield (I mean the horrible-things-descend-on-city part, not the shaky camera part). Probably ditch the magnetite usage. Also a sweet fight between the Hero (plus party) and Gotou (plus underwear and black evil slime things), or with Yuriko, or...
 
...
 
Never mind. They'll probably just give it to Owe Bo... *dies*
 
Back to top
 
 
Email View Profile   IP Logged
SHODAN
Full Member
***


I Wub Nodens-Wodens

Posts: 249
Gender: female
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #5 - 04/15/08 at 23:46:04
 
I'd say forget about SMT or Megaten and do March of the Penguins but with Prinnies
Back to top
 
 
View Profile WWW   IP Logged
Spider Bike
Senior Member
****




Posts: 350
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #6 - 04/16/08 at 00:03:36
 
Quote from SHODAN on 04/15/08 at 23:46:04:
I'd say forget about SMT or Megaten and do March of the Penguins but with Prinnies

 
You could never get enough footage. One bump and a chainsplosion would end all filming.
Back to top
 
 
View Profile   IP Logged
Angel Heart
Less Newbies
*


The Devil That Lives
In Georgia

Posts: 32
Gender: male
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #7 - 04/16/08 at 13:33:27
 
Quote from EzraSolomon on 04/15/08 at 23:43:31:
>> I think an SMT movie could work if they played to the horror/invasion aspect, a la The Host or Cloverfield (I mean the horrible-things-descend-on-city part, not the shaky camera part). Probably ditch the magnetite usage. Also a sweet fight between the Hero (plus party) and Gotou (plus underwear and black evil slime things), or with Yuriko, or...

...

Never mind. They'll probably just give it to Owe Bo... *dies*


 
 
 Ow crap I forgot that he is still working. Maybe I should fix the poll for the no option
Back to top
 
 

Moo
View Profile   IP Logged
neonecron
Junior Member
**


I Love Jack Frost!
Persona Text?

Posts: 93
Gender: male
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #8 - 04/17/08 at 01:35:39
 
No way they could do this a movie successfully unless it was for art over entertainment.
and even then it would still be too hard.
Back to top
 
 

Here is a signature. I rushed this badly so don't kill yoke.
Email View Profile WWW neonecron   IP Logged
Spider Bike
Senior Member
****




Posts: 350
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #9 - 04/17/08 at 01:41:42
 
Yeah, no need to assume Uwe Boll is the sole reason for shitty game movies.
Back to top
 
 
View Profile   IP Logged
MutheSquirrel
Junior Member
**


Hanged Man

Posts: 56
Gender: male
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #10 - 04/17/08 at 07:33:24
 
...why would it matter if they were main stream...? Uh, anyway, no. Pretty much for the same reason Brand said. Whenever I think of video games becoming movies I think of Street Fighter..and Escape from New York...
Back to top
 
 

I dream of the day Vegetable Lamb turns up in a Megaten game... ;-;
Email View Profile MutheSquirrel lordclaws   IP Logged
Angel Heart
Less Newbies
*


The Devil That Lives
In Georgia

Posts: 32
Gender: male
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #11 - 04/17/08 at 10:13:35
 
Quote from MutheSquirrel on 04/17/08 at 07:33:24:
...why would it matter if they were main stream...? Uh, anyway, no. Pretty much for the same reason Brand said. Whenever I think of video games becoming movies I think of Street Fighter..and Escape from New York...

 
 
 The mainstream option was just for those losers that believes creators "sell out" when there creations hit it big
Back to top
 
 

Moo
View Profile   IP Logged
Spider Bike
Senior Member
****




Posts: 350
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #12 - 04/17/08 at 22:11:16
 
Quote from MutheSquirrel on 04/17/08 at 07:33:24:
...why would it matter if they were main stream...? Uh, anyway, no. Pretty much for the same reason Brand said. Whenever I think of video games becoming movies I think of Street Fighter..and Escape from New York...

 
Since when was Escape from New york a movie adaptation of a video game?
Back to top
 
 
View Profile   IP Logged
neonecron
Junior Member
**


I Love Jack Frost!
Persona Text?

Posts: 93
Gender: male
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #13 - 04/18/08 at 17:51:35
 
Quote from Angel Heart on 04/17/08 at 10:13:35:
Quote from MutheSquirrel on 04/17/08 at 07:33:24:
...why would it matter if they were main stream...? Uh, anyway, no. Pretty much for the same reason Brand said. Whenever I think of video games becoming movies I think of Street Fighter..and Escape from New York...



The mainstream option was just for those losers that believes creators "sell out" when there creations hit it big

Yes, but look at the style the games are.
Back to top
 
 

Here is a signature. I rushed this badly so don't kill yoke.
Email View Profile WWW neonecron   IP Logged
Angel Heart
Less Newbies
*


The Devil That Lives
In Georgia

Posts: 32
Gender: male
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #14 - 04/18/08 at 18:41:58
 
Quote from neonecron on 04/18/08 at 17:51:35:
Quote from Angel Heart on 04/17/08 at 10:13:35:
Quote from MutheSquirrel on 04/17/08 at 07:33:24:
...why would it matter if they were main stream...? Uh, anyway, no. Pretty much for the same reason Brand said. Whenever I think of video games becoming movies I think of Street Fighter..and Escape from New York...



The mainstream option was just for those losers that believes creators "sell out" when there creations hit it big

Yes, but look at the style the games are.

 
 ?????
Back to top
 
 

Moo
View Profile   IP Logged
Kanzato
Less Newbies
*


I <3 Jack Frost!

Posts: 10
Gender: male
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #15 - 04/19/08 at 12:56:30
 
Seeing the live action they do with the commercials.. they're fun, but they're commercials quality. I wouldn't mind some live action as bonus with a game or something.
Back to top
 
 
Email View Profile   IP Logged
Ayato
Less Newbies
*


long live the new
flesh

Posts: 7
Gender: male
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #16 - 06/08/08 at 23:59:04
 
David Lynch, Jodorowsky, or the Brothers Quay could make a badass megaten movie. My personal pics anyway.
Back to top
 
 
Email View Profile Ayato9   IP Logged
0kami7777
Junior Member
**


I Love Jack Frost!

Posts: 89
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #17 - 06/10/08 at 21:23:04
 
^ David Lynch...hmmm...If he did a SMT series movie, I imagine either the part where the main character goes to the Velvet Room in Persona or the Master's library in Nocturne, would look pretty much like this...
 
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gMXjjHFz__A
Back to top
 
 
View Profile   IP Logged
0kami7777
Junior Member
**


I Love Jack Frost!

Posts: 89
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #18 - 06/26/08 at 21:31:22
 
I think they would have to conceive of a whole new story that while followed the outline and themes of the games (the rules, if you will) would have to be self contained. It's hard to translate the hours of gameplay an SMT game takes into a film.
 
I do have all summer though and a nice program called Celtex that's perfect for screenplays and stageplays. I could think up perhaps an SMT or Persona movie, but it wouldn't follow any of the game. Maybe some other people here could think up some plots just for the heck of it?
Back to top
 
 
View Profile   IP Logged
Sir_Asura
Full Member
***


Failure to Comply

Posts: 129
Gender: male
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #19 - 06/26/08 at 22:32:43
 
Personally... I think Persona should become a TV drama.  It'd either be the most hilarious live action series ever, or really compelling. .... I also would vote to have it take place not in Japan, or if in Japan, maybe at an international school... as a compromise.
Back to top
 
 
View Profile ErringArgonaut   IP Logged
Angel Heart
Less Newbies
*


The Devil That Lives
In Georgia

Posts: 32
Gender: male
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #20 - 06/26/08 at 23:44:17
 
Quote from 0kami7777 on 06/26/08 at 21:31:22:
I think they would have to conceive of a whole new story that while followed the outline and themes of the games (the rules, if you will) would have to be self contained. It's hard to translate the hours of gameplay an SMT game takes into a film.

I do have all summer though and a nice program called Celtex that's perfect for screenplays and stageplays. I could think up perhaps an SMT or Persona movie, but it wouldn't follow any of the game. Maybe some other people here could think up some plots just for the heck of it?

 
 
    I wished we had a higher character mark than 5500 cuz' I've got something lol
Back to top
 
 

Moo
View Profile   IP Logged
0kami7777
Junior Member
**


I Love Jack Frost!

Posts: 89
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #21 - 06/26/08 at 23:48:26
 
Yeah...I think I'm going to ahead and come upwith something. A Persona game's plot but with original characters, and I hate to say it, but i think it might be set in America (though this time with it being INTENTIONALLY set there, not one of those let's whitewash Japan and change people's races P1 jobs).  
 
If anything, the key to Persona is its artsy vibes and its character analysis, plus the varying degrees of psychological elements.
 
But a question first. Implement the Velvet room, right? Wink
Back to top
 
 
View Profile   IP Logged
0kami7777
Junior Member
**


I Love Jack Frost!

Posts: 89
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #22 - 07/01/08 at 18:01:03
 
Well, I started writing up a rough outline of characters and some plot based ideas. Right now I'm torn between a weird amalgam of the first three Persona games or a totally new plot altogether with no referances or character roles similar to the first three games.  
 
For example, a problem I'm stuck with is that 3 of the cahracters are basically American versions of Tastuya, Katusyam and Maya (a school kid, his brother detective, and a reporter) but it's not really them so it feels odd. Everyone else is mostly secular.
Back to top
 
 
View Profile   IP Logged
RMarques
Junior Member
**


I Love Jack Frost!

Posts: 77
Gender: male
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #23 - 07/01/08 at 19:37:51
 
Well then fool around with them a bit. Make one have a lazy eye, make the detective brother a detective sister, give someone a drinking problem, something that makes them a bit different from the base. Tongue
Back to top
 
 
Email View Profile   IP Logged
Sir_Asura
Full Member
***


Failure to Comply

Posts: 129
Gender: male
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #24 - 07/01/08 at 22:06:25
 
I had some ideas for characters that were based on racial stereotypes/stigmas.  Have you thought about adding characters who are perhaps 1st or 2nd generation Americans?  Adding the ethnic factor is something that is sorta (but not completely) unique to the American setting.
Back to top
 
 
View Profile ErringArgonaut   IP Logged
0kami7777
Junior Member
**


I Love Jack Frost!

Posts: 89
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #25 - 07/01/08 at 23:31:45
 
I have been working on a book sort of like the Persona series that deals with multi-ethnic inner city kids. I'll probably have a few diversified characters, but race won't be the focus.
Back to top
 
 
View Profile   IP Logged
Raidou11
Less Newbies
*




Posts: 15
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #26 - 07/13/08 at 14:44:31
 
Sounds good, but it better not be live-action. That doesn't work for megaten games!
Back to top
 
 
View Profile   IP Logged
crimsonutterfly
Newbies
*


Oh, yes, I do
comprehend.

Posts: 4
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #27 - 07/13/08 at 15:28:04
 
augh double nay ;;
Back to top
 
 
View Profile   IP Logged
Ikkaris
Less Newbies
*


The Amazing
Sword-swallowing Man

Posts: 23
Gender: male
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #28 - 08/04/08 at 00:09:53
 
Mmm perhaps Persona would work better for a movie. P3 in particular is cheesy enough.
Id cast White Fang as Koromaru, Jude Law as Ryoji and  Megan Fox as Mitsuru. Rawr Wink
Back to top
 
 
View Profile   IP Logged
reprogamado
Newbies
*


I Love Jack Frost!

Posts: 1
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #29 - 08/05/08 at 02:45:13
 
The whole thing about high school students/demons makes me thinks about go-nagai kinda thing... of course ol go nagai was way to far from computers but gakuen shinigamis shure was his thing... So there is a japanese real action movie of devilman, which is a way of visualize how an actual movie about shin megami tensei could possibly look. the there are some other strange japanese movie, cashern, about a tatsunoko hero, much more arty than the devilman movie, which is another way of visualize how could be a japanes take on this kind of story. last, lets not forget about one of the early spin off of the shin megami tensei games, called SMT IF..., the first game that actualy takes place in a high school. It is said that this game is based or influenced but a british cult movie called IF..., from the sixties, starring Malcom Mc Dowel and directed by Lindsay Anderson. This movie is about a school where misterious things start to happen to students and then some kind of rebellion came up... And thats as far as I can go thinking about movies and SMT...
Back to top
 
 
View Profile   IP Logged
neonecron
Junior Member
**


I Love Jack Frost!
Persona Text?

Posts: 93
Gender: male
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #30 - 08/14/08 at 17:47:59
 
That's pretty cool
Back to top
 
 

Here is a signature. I rushed this badly so don't kill yoke.
Email View Profile WWW neonecron   IP Logged
Vicious1915
Newbies
*


I Love Jack Frost!

Posts: 4
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #31 - 01/04/09 at 09:04:36
 
Quote from 0kami7777 on 03/30/08 at 20:38:47:
Last year a few of my freinds got together over the weekend and thought it would be funny to make what a trailer for a Persona 2 movie would look like (a mock trailer, not real). We filmed a few days worth of footage with our crappy school's camera and then we spliced up footage in iMovie. It was fun but the product is well...it's for laughs, trust me.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B9OvPtm8qZs

Enjoy. And be thankful that there isn't a SMT movie. Though if planned out, I'm sure a stand-alone story wouldn't be too half bad.

 
Well I have to say, that was a very very decent attempt, and really good casting for having no budget and, I'm assuming, remaining in your own local area. I loved it!
Back to top
 
 
Email View Profile   IP Logged
Spider Bike
Senior Member
****




Posts: 350
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #32 - 05/21/09 at 03:35:17
 
Quote from Vicious1915 on 01/04/09 at 09:04:36:
Quote from 0kami7777 on 03/30/08 at 20:38:47:
Last year a few of my freinds got together over the weekend and thought it would be funny to make what a trailer for a Persona 2 movie would look like (a mock trailer, not real). We filmed a few days worth of footage with our crappy school's camera and then we spliced up footage in iMovie. It was fun but the product is well...it's for laughs, trust me.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B9OvPtm8qZs

Enjoy. And be thankful that there isn't a SMT movie. Though if planned out, I'm sure a stand-alone story wouldn't be too half bad.


Well I have to say, that was a very very decent attempt, and really good casting for having no budget and, I'm assuming, remaining in your own local area. I loved it!

 
I didn't. I thought it was terrible.
Back to top
 
 
View Profile   IP Logged
cattz
Newbies
*


I Love Jack Frost!

Posts: 4
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #33 - 05/31/09 at 16:17:32
 
I had to register just so I could stress how miserable it would be.
 
If you guys have Share (japanese p2p program) you could download the megaten t.v. show.
 
The cg is beyond ridiculous and horrid when mixed in with the live action.
 
At best they could make it an anime with today's production values/animation unlike the past one.
 
Back to top
 
 
View Profile   IP Logged
Spider Bike
Senior Member
****




Posts: 350
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #34 - 06/01/09 at 00:02:39
 
Quote from cattz on 05/31/09 at 16:17:32:
I had to register just so I could stress how miserable it would be.

If you guys have Share (japanese p2p program) you could download the megaten t.v. show.

The cg is beyond ridiculous and horrid when mixed in with the live action.

At best they could make it an anime with today's production values/animation unlike the past one.


 
As much as I'd like to see an SMT japanimation rather than a live action CGI clusterfuck, I'd rather SMT stay in the form it's in now. Game form.
Back to top
 
 
View Profile   IP Logged
Mudo
Less Newbies
*


I Love Jack Frost!

Posts: 7
Re: SMT Movie
Reply #35 - 08/28/09 at 12:17:13
 
No.  I like SMT underground. =/
 
Really though, if they made a live action movie, it would suck balls like the other 99% of videogame movies.  An animated movie, though, could be interesting.
Back to top
 
 
Email View Profile   IP Logged
Pages: 1 
Send Topic Print