Who thinks that DDS would make a really interesting Multiplayer game? PErsonally I am thinking something along the lines of Warhawk on the PS3.
 
I mean the World of Junkyard seems really fun in that way
 
What do you guys think?

Yeah my thought process would almost be that you would have to do it BEFORE everyone got their Atma, because once that started is when things came to a head.

Until someone got Null Attack.
 
It really would have to operate under an expanded spell system. There just aren't enough abilities to stop it from being boring.
 
A Persona online game... that has potential.

Elimination is never good.
 
I would instead suggest that they be exceptionally rare.

I'm of the opinion that if you put in the work, youshould be able to get what you want in an RP.

Well certainly, but won't that only be a problem in the event you go for an extreme focus?
 
Then again... the way SMT is set up, you pretty much just need the highest tier skill. Hm.

I'll take Megidolaon. And Null Death. ^^ That one should be allowed, since nobody likes instant death.
 
I don't think you'd kill the Megaten aspect of the game if you removed or altered those skills though. Maybe a spell that gives you Null ______ for five minutes. Maybe more, maybe less. You could cast it on others at higher levels. Tons of ways to pull it off fairly, I guess I'm saying.

I take is none of you have played warhawk.  
 
Think of it as battlefield or counterstrike.
 
Basically you get a soldier that you can customize a little and this soldier gets dumped on a map with other soldiers. You start with a handgun, a knife and 2 grenades. Your objective is to kill everyone that does not happen to be your character or on your teams character.  
 
Oh plus there are fights planes and tanks and stuff.  
 
Atma abilities would basically have to be scaled down so that when you transform, there will be a bar that represents the amount of time you have in this form ( say a few seconds) in this form all of your fire arms turn into magic attacks (dependant on the weapon you picked up) and your melee attack has a chance of devouring the opponent, getting more health than if you just killed them normally and picked up their items.  
 
There is no real room for RPing, just massive killing. Thus if null abilities were brought in, say goodbye to balance and fair play.

I actually hijacked the topic and completely ignored Warhawk, ahahhaha.
 
I wouldn't do too much PvP to tell the truth, though you could implement Law/Chaos that way.
 
Honestly, Persona is a better game in terms of PvP and RP potential. I once read the char descs of a Nocturne RP and I wanted to hurl. I mean... what, Michael becoming a Fallen? That one guy's Tsukoyomi Moon God being absurdly overpowered? What the hell.

It's a lot to do with the fact that in Nocturne, you can customize to create a pretty good skillset. If you get something really good, what happens? You get copied.
 
A Persona RP can prevent such things, as the GM would to an extent control what skillsets you can have. Of course, you should allow customization in the form of Spell Cards, equipment, and innate boosts.

whatever happened to THAT THING on THAT PLACE anyways, toggies

I like the sound of it, but would it be F2P?

That's good.
Whilst I understand that companies that run MMs have to bring in money, at the same time I think it's bullshit how some of them charge high amounts just to play.