Sir_Asura
Full Member
Failure to Comply
Posts: 129
Gender:
|
Yeah, it is a stretch for Star Lucifer to work. Of course, I am not as upset by the arbitrary Tarot classifications because the arcana simply function as a means of organization and are just kind of a dumb bit of "game mechanics." There's, to my knowledge, zero connection between that aspect of the game and the connections to Jungian philosophy, where the archetyping gets its most strength. I also forgot to mention in my above post, what happened to playing with the idea of the collective unconscious? I mean seriously, that's game fodder right there--want a strong glue to bind and rehabilitate bs rpg cliches, collective unconscious, you're my bff. For serious. It's from the collective unconscious that we get our archetypal heroes that span cross-cultural barriers. The whole card aspect of the game I am pretty indifferent to. I think it organizes the game nicely, but is generally fluffy and unnecessary. The exclusivity of persona to characters was a nice change in Persona 3, because it allowed for those characters to have a more important connection to their personae, but that was ultimately ruined by the thoughtless connections between character and persona. Junpei and Hermes? Mmm, don't get it? Maybe I can see Yukari's connection, since she felt bonded to fate, blah blah. If each character were to be exclusively bound to a Persona, I could see the card system going out the door. Of course, that could eliminate an entire aspect of "monster collecting" from the game, but there's no reason the Velvet Room couldn't function in other ways. If the evoker were to return, why couldn't the monster collecting system revolve around that? Monsters could perhaps be classified like they were in Nocturne. Or if the Tarot system is to stay in tact, then I would prefer to see certain arcana reacting better to certain personalities like in Persona 2. It could get really elaborate, with the social link system getting combined with the Velvet Room system of the older incarnations of the series.
|