I definitely prefer the story and gameplay of P2 over P3.
Fusion spells > Mix Raids.
Tartarus was boring, and the city map was repetitive. There were just so many more things to do in P2.
I liked the contact system and Nyar is just more awesome than Nyx. When I was playing P3 and found out Nyx was the boss and some ultimate baddie that couldn't be defeated, I was like "really...huh?" She was pretty high ranking in the SMT games, but boss worthy? I guess it made sense plotwise.
I do really like P3's characters, but Tatsuya and Maya were better MCs. And Guido...come on...Guido the Japanese Italian Persona wielding zombie.
Now, does anyone have any idea what Nameless is talking about in these pictures? +bonus pics!